Maloney Rings Closing Bell at NYSE, Releases Women’s Economic Report in Honor of Women’s Equality Day
NEW YORK— Today, two days after the nation marked the 98th Anniversary of the 19th Amendment, Congresswoman Carolyn B. Maloney (NY-12) rang the Closing Bell at NYSE in honor of Women’s Equality Day and released a new report, “Earn Less, Pay More: The State of the Gender Pay Gap and’ Pink Tax’ in 2018,” documenting the state of economic inequality women still face today.
Rep. Maloney was joined by women leaders from business, government, and non-profits at both events. A video of the bell ringing can be viewed here and the full press conference about the report can be viewed here.
The “Earn Less, Pay More” report reveals small steps toward progress on ending the “pink tax” but shows that there is still a long way to reach fair pricing for women as we continue to fight the gender pay gap. In 2016, Rep. Maloney and Sen. Bob Casey (D-PA) requested that the GAO study the “pink tax” and gendered pricing. That report, released the by the Members last week, also highlights a number of disturbing cost discrepancies, including in mortgages, automobile loans, and in personal care products. The Maloney report expands on these findings and examines the compounding effects of pricing differences and the gender pay gap.
“As we celebrate Women’s Equality Day and commemorate the certification of the 19th Amendment, we must make a commitment to continue the fight that the suffragettes started a century ago,” said Congresswoman Maloney. “A woman’s right to vote is the only right we have guaranteed by the Constitution and that is not acceptable. We must not rest until full democratic rights are secured for women by passing the Equal Rights Amendment. With this legal bedrock, we will have the backing we need to fight the gender pay gap, sexual harassment & assault, and gendered pricing. Together, we can make history and create a more equitable world for generations to come.”
“We’ve made progress when it comes to equal rights for women in New York, but we still have a lot of work to do,” said Lieutenant Governor Kathy Hochul, who attended the bell-ringing event. “New York has the smallest wage gap in the nation, but the gap is still there. On Women’s Equality Day, we remember the sacrifices the suffragists made 100 years ago to secure full citizenship, and we continue to fight in their honor to reach full equality once and for all.”
“I commend Congresswoman Carolyn Maloney for her leadership in exposing the so-called Pink Tax, which might also be known as the Pocketbook Tax on Products,” said Assembly Member Rebecca Seawright. “It is a Pocketbook Tax that rips off the hard-earned wages of women, wages that are too often below what equal pay for equal work demands. It is a Pocketbook Tax that effectively picks the pockets of women and their families by unfair and higher prices for products solely due to their gender usage. It is a Pocketbook Tax that is emblematic of the kind of economic discrimination that all Americans, female or male, should oppose as contrary to the letter and spirit of equal protection under the law.”
This important report is spot on in its conclusion that final ratification of the Equal Rights Amendment (ERA) to the Constitution is the most effective solution to stop the Pink Tax and unequal wage and benefits,” said ERA Coalition Co-President and CEO Carol Robles-Román. “Americans overwhelming support equal rights in the Constitution: the report cites the ERA Coalition's 2016 highly publicized bipartisan poll that shows that more than 90 percent of Americans believe that the Constitution should guarantee equal rights for men and women. We call for passage of the ERA so that women are recognized by the U.S. Constitution, thus giving women equal legal and economic standing.”
“On Sunday, August 26, we celebrated and honored the 98th anniversary of women’s patriation and access to the ballot box,” said National Organization for Women (NOW) President Toni Van Pelt. “In its honor, NOW we're announcing our agenda for our “2020 vision” which we hope to achieve as we celebrate the centennial of our emancipation in two years. Part of our “2020 vision” includes recognizing the Gender Pay Gap, which can cost women well over half a million dollars over a lifetime. The Pink Tax only adds to that. NOW members and supporters in every state will be united and forceful as we work for this vision and we will be joined by coalition partners as we work for legal, economic and social justice, safe schools and communities and fair treatment for all in a world where we revere our land and our people.”
"The Pink Tax is yet another way women are treated as second class citizens,” saidNational Women’s Political Caucus (NWPC) President Donna Lent. “While women have had to face the Gender Pay Gap, being paid less than men for doing the same work, the Pink Tax is expecting women to pay more simply for being a woman. We need to pass an Equal Rights Amendment to stop this unfair discrimination against women and make it unlawful."
Among those who joined the Congresswoman for today’s events were: New York State Lieutenant Governor Kathy Hochul, Assembly Member Rebecca Seawright, Co-President and CEO Of the ERA Coalition Carol Robles-Román,
Co-Founder and Co-President of the ERA Coalition Jessica Neuwirth, National Organization for Women (NOW) President Toni Van Pelt, National Women’s Political Caucus (NWPC) President Donna Lent, Co-Founder and CEO of #VOTEPROCHOICE Heidi Sieck, President and CEO of the Manhattan Chamber of Commerce Jessica Walker, National Women’s Hall of Fame Board Member Kathy Bonk, President and CEO of the National Black Leadership Commission on AIDS C. Virginia Fields, Women’s Rights Attorney Sybil Shainwald, Executive Director of Women’s eNews Lori Sokol, Founder of She Will Rise Tricia Shimamura, Downtown Magazine Owner Grace Capobianco, Moms Demand Action Volunteer Linda Dunn, Vice-Chair of the New York State Democratic Committee Trudy Mason, LGBTQ Rights Advocate Judith Kasen Windsor, and Upper East Siders for Change Organizer Monica Atiya.
The ERA is a constitutional amendment which would prohibit denying or abridging equal rights under law by the United States or any state on account of sex. This critical amendment would guarantee the equal rights of men and women by:
- Making sex a suspect category subject to strict judicial scrutiny, clarifying the legal status of sex discrimination for the courts. This would prohibit sexual discrimination in the same way we have prohibited discrimination on the basis of race, religion, and national origin.
- Guaranteeing equal footing for women in the legal systems of all 50 states.
- Ensuring that government programs and federal resources benefit men and women equally.
Key “Earn Less, Pay More” report findings:
- Thanks to consumer advocacy and greater public awareness, some retailers have eliminated or shrunk the pink tax on products for which side-by-side comparisons are possible, like toys, sporting goods, office supplies and back-to-school items.
- Prices on personal care products are obscured by different sizes and item counts, and prices for women continue to be higher than those for men.
- Price differences on personal care products and other frequently purchased items can add up to large sums over long periods.
- The marketing practice of using constantly shifting “sale” prices may mask gender-based pricing.
- The effect of the pink tax on women’s wallets is made even worse by the gender pay gap, which recent research shows may be even larger than previously thought.
- The gender pay gap can cost women more than half a million dollars over a lifetime. The pink tax only adds to that.